Stargate SG-1 Pwned by YouTube Insurgents


Geeks among you might know that UK's Sky One has been airing the latest Stargate SG-1 episodes months ahead of the US's Sci-Fi Channel.

In fact, last night Sky One aired the Stargate SG-1 series finale.

We have had evidence for some time that the decision to delay airing in the US was not made with a deep understanding of the passion or technical savvy of the Stargate SG-1 fan base. Witness to both: already by today, at least two users have uploaded the series finale onto YouTube, in four or five less-than-ten minute segments, to meet YouTube's 10 minute per clip limit.

That's after the biggest Stargate copyright violator of them all -- who was uploading every single new episode of Stargate SG-1 and backfilling earlier ones -- had his account suspended.

At one point, illegal episodes of Stargate were so easy to find on YouTube, I had assumed that the copyright owner was being extremely progressive and tactful -- understanding that core viewership of these shoddy-quality uploaded versions is extremely likely to purchase the season DVDs in addition to watching the episodes online. Let them have their fun, and 99.5% of regular viewers won't even know about it.

But I was wrong: the copyright holders were worried about the impact of the 0.5%, but they were, apparently indecisive, lethargic, or incompetent.

Can it possibly be worth it financially to stop a couple of hundred, or even a few thousand people from sharing these episodes with one another?

And besides counterinsurgency, what can YouTube reasonably do to stop this insurgent community from taking countermeasures: opening up shell accounts for each episode, uploading the videos while misrepresenting the content in words, and distributing links among a trusted network? A loss of one account means nothing if multiple accounts hold identical content, or if files are retained by several seeders who can repost banned content to new accounts within hours.


Plus, there a couple of sites now where you can upload video to as well, undoubtedly in various juridictions. Dailymotion is a youtube like site.

It appears that YouTube and Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios Inc. are fighting hard; the original uploads I had found are already gone. However, a new user posted the same material, only parts of which have been deleted.

Again, staggered showings in different countries has made copyright infringement far more worthwhile, as evidenced by this comment from the link above:

valamoss | March 15, 2007
Thank you for posting this, despite copy right. i live in 
 Australia and won't get to see it for a long time,
 so thank u from the bottom of my heart.


Powered by Movable Type 5.02

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Kevin published on March 14, 2007 12:00 PM.

Free Krugman was the previous entry in this blog.

Subprime is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.